Coaching · Consulting · Facilitation · Training
LeadershipTeam Performance

How the Best Leaders Run 1:1s — and Why Most Get It Backwards

Kerri SuteyKerri Sutey
5 min read
Read Article

Most managers run 1:1s as status updates. The best leaders use them as the single most powerful tool for developing people, building trust, and driving results. Here's the difference.

The one-on-one is the most underutilized tool in a manager's toolkit. Used well, it's where trust is built, development happens, problems get surfaced early, and people feel genuinely seen and supported. Used poorly — or not at all — it's a missed week, a status update, or the meeting that always gets canceled when things get busy.

The single biggest mistake most managers make with 1:1s is treating them as updates from employee to manager. 'What are you working on? Any blockers? Great, see you next week.'

That's not a 1:1. That's a check-in, and it produces very little beyond the illusion of communication.

Whose Meeting Is This, Anyway?

The most important reframe in running effective 1:1s: this meeting belongs to your direct report, not to you.

That doesn't mean you're passive. It means the agenda — the things that get discussed, the questions that get asked, the direction the conversation goes — should be primarily shaped by what that person needs, not by what you need to know.

When managers run 1:1s as their own status collection tool, they're optimizing for their own information needs. When employees run 1:1s, they get support, perspective, challenge, and the experience of being genuinely heard by someone who has power to help them.

Which one builds trust?

What Great 1:1s Actually Include

A standing structure (flexible enough to breathe)

The best 1:1s aren't freeform and they're not rigid. They have a loose structure that creates safety and efficiency without killing the conversation. Something like: What's top of mind for you? What progress have you made since we last met? Where do you need support or input? What's one thing about your development you want to focus on this week?

These four questions take about five minutes to work through — and they create space for almost everything important to surface naturally.

Time for the things that don't surface elsewhere

Status updates happen in team meetings and project tools. Your 1:1 should be the place for what doesn't fit anywhere else: the frustration that's been building, the idea the person isn't sure is worth raising, the career question they've been sitting with, the interpersonal dynamic they're not sure how to navigate.

Creating that space requires two things: trust (which takes time) and explicit invitation. 'Is there anything you're carrying right now that we haven't talked about?' asked with genuine curiosity opens doors that would otherwise stay closed.

Development, not just performance

Most managers wait for a performance cycle to have development conversations. The best leaders weave them into every 1:1. Not in a formal way — but with ongoing attention to each person's growth, goals, and what's stretching them.

'What did you learn this week?' 'Where did you feel most energized?' 'What's one thing you'd want to do differently if you had it to do over?' These questions aren't about evaluation. They're about building a practice of reflection and growth that develops people over time.

Honest feedback — in both directions

The 1:1 is the right context for direct, specific, timely feedback — both giving and inviting. Not a full performance review. A specific observation: 'In Tuesday's meeting, the way you framed the problem shifted the entire conversation — that was really effective.' Or: 'I noticed you seemed hesitant to push back on the stakeholder decision. I'd like to hear what was behind that.'

And then: 'What feedback do you have for me? Is there anything I'm doing — or not doing — that's making your work harder?'

Most managers don't ask this. The ones who do learn things that transform their leadership.

The Logistics That Matter

Keep them consistent. A 1:1 that gets canceled when things get busy sends a message: you're not a priority when things get hard. That's exactly the wrong time to cancel.

Keep them private. Not in open offices, not over walk-and-talks where conversations are overheard. The depth of conversation you can have is directly related to the safety of the environment.

Keep them off Slack. A quick check-in message is not a 1:1. Human conversation, even on video, is categorically different.

The 15 minutes you invest in a genuine, well-run 1:1 returns more in trust, retention, and performance than hours of performance management on the back end.

If your 1:1s have drifted into status updates — or they've been dropping off the calendar — this is the week to reset them. The investment is small. The return is significant.

Ready to Transform Your Leadership?

Put these insights into action with personalized coaching and consulting tailored to your unique challenges.

Schedule a Discovery Call